CHEMUNI联合化学Polycarboxylate ethers

02 · Technical note

What the methylene blue value tells you — and what it does not

MB is a clay test, not an admixture test. Reading it as a dosage instruction is how good sand gets rejected and bad mixes get blamed on the polymer.

The test measures adsorption, not clay content

Methylene blue is a cationic dye. It binds to negatively charged surfaces — clay edges, organic matter, and to a lesser degree the fines in the sand. The value in g/kg is the mass of dye the sand absorbs per kilogram. That makes it a proxy for how much surface is available to adsorb a polymer, which is why it correlates with PCE demand. It is not a clay content, and it does not identify the clay.

Three different things are called mud

Montmorillonite has an expanding interlayer and will absorb polyethylene oxide side chains between its layers. Per gram, its effect on a PCE is the worst of the common clays. Illite adsorbs on its edges and faces — less per gram, still enough to matter. Stone powder, the fines produced when crushed sand is made, is not clay at all, but it raises the MB value and the water demand together.

The practical consequence: two sands with the same MB can need different answers. One needs a clay-tolerant grade. The other needs a change in fines content, a higher paste volume, or simply more water.

Where the 1.4 figure comes from

1.4 g/kg is a widely used threshold above which a sand is treated as clay-bearing and the mix is expected to need a sacrificial anchor. It is a convention, not a specification, and it was derived for a particular test method and a particular set of aggregates. A sand at 1.3 is not safe, and a sand at 1.6 is not automatically a problem: the mix, the cement and the water content still decide.

A number that changes what you test next is useful. A number that replaces the test is not.

What to do with a high MB

Do not start by raising the dosage. Start by finding out what changed:

  • Re-run the MB on a washed sample. If the value drops sharply, the problem is the fines, not the clay.
  • Run a paste flow at fixed dosage with the suspect sand and with a washed reference sand. The difference is the clay's cost, in millimetres.
  • Only then try a clay-tolerant grade at the same dosage and compare. If it recovers most of the flow, the diagnosis was right.

If the clay is seasonal, blending the standard grade with the clay-tolerant one is often cheaper than switching the whole silo. The ratio can follow the MB value — but only after both ends of the range have been measured.

Send us your numbers

Cement type, sand MB value, haul time and temperature. The reply carries a dosage and a blend ratio, not a referral to a local agent.